John F. Gelson Mediation & Resolution Services

About

John F. Gelson

Mediator • Business Counsel • Trial Attorney

Serving across the United States since 1995

John F. Gelson has served as a mediator, business counsel, trial attorney, and legal advisor for more than four decades.

Since 1995, he has conducted more than 1,500 mediations across commercial, construction, employment, franchise, and complex business disputes.

Known for his practical judgment, calm demeanor, and ability to resolve difficult matters efficiently, John is trusted by attorneys, business leaders, insurance carriers, and private clients throughout the United States.

Professional Experience

  1. VP & General Counsel

    Jersey Mike's Franchise Systems, Inc.

    2011 – 2025

    Served as General Counsel during the company's expansion from 300 locations to more than 3,500 restaurants and $3.5 billion in sales. Guided legal matters through the company's $8 billion acquisition by Blackstone.

  2. Founder

    NJ Mediator Resolution Services

    1995 – Present

    Conducted more than 1,500 mediations across franchise, commercial, construction, and complex civil matters.

  3. Senior Partner

    McLaughlin, Bennett & Gelson

    1993 – 2012

  4. Senior Partner

    Rothstein, Mandell, Strohm & Gelson

    1981 – 1993

    Tried more than 100 jury and non-jury cases in federal and state courts.

Certifications & Recognition

  • Certified by the Supreme Court of New Jersey as a Court-Appointed Mediator since 1995
  • AV Rated by Martindale-Hubbell™
  • Best Lawyers in America™
  • New Jersey Super Lawyer™
  • National Association of Distinguished Mediators

Education

  • University of Notre Dame B.A., English
  • Notre Dame Law School, London, England International Law
  • Drake University Law School J.D.

“The mediator everyone wants in the room.”